Start by choosing a shape (round, square, or sheet);  then select a size, flavor, filling and frosting;  pick from one of our standard decorations.

Et voila! A perfect cake that's yours to enjoy! 

​

Before continuing please be advised that, due to our production schedule, we

can not make changes to cake orders inside of a 72 hour window from the selected pick up date.  

Now, let's get started!

Cake Shapes & Sizes Chart

ATTENTION!  YOU WILL RECEIVE AN AUTOMATED RESPONSE AFTER YOUR ORDER IS  SUCCESSFULLY SUBMITTED.  

​

PLEASE ALLOW UP TO 72 HOURS FOR A MRS. GOODMAN'S EMPLOYEE TO CONFIRM YOUR ORDER.  IF YOU DO NOT RECEIVE THESE NOTIFICATIONS AFTER 72 HOURS PLEASE CONTACT THE BAKERY AT (614)888-7437.