Holiday Menu 2025

Holiday Cakes

Merry Little Moments

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

X-mas Swag

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

Dasher

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

Poinsettias

6" (serves 6-8)

$43.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$60.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$79.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

Merry & Bright

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

White Christmas

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

Santa's Belt

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

Snowflakes

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

Snowman

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

Christmas Grinch

6" (serves 6-8)

$74.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$95.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$118.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Choc 1/2 Vanilla

Yule Log (serves 6-8)

This 8" Yule Log is made using our delicious chocolate cake filled with original vanilla buttercream, coated in chocolate buttercream and adorned with beautiful poinsettias. Both a Christmas classic and beautiful table centerpiece.

$52.95

Half Ornament Cake

A smaller version of our full sphere ornament cake! Serves 8-10

$44.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

Ornament Cake

Almost too pretty to eat! Our full sphere ornament cake comes in chocolate or vanilla cake decorated to look like a beautiful Christmas ornament. Choose between Red, Green or Christmas Blue. Serves 20-24

$82.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Choc 1/2 Vanilla

Red Nosed Reindeer

6" (serves 6-8)

$44.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$65.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$88.95

Flavor

Chocolate

Vanilla

1/2 Chocolate, 1/2 Vanilla

Peppermint Kiss

Our delicious chocolate cake filled with chocolate peppermint buttercream, covered in our original buttercream and topped with chocolate ganache and candy canes.

6" (serves 6-8)

$47.95

8" (serves 12-16)

$70.95

10" (serves 20-30)

$95.95

Inscription

Merry Christmas!

Happy Holidays!

Joy!

Cookies!

*Party Size* Cookie Tray

A smaller version of our delicious homemade cookies.

Small Tray (1 dz cookies)

$19.95

Medium Tray (2 dz cookies)

$34.95

Large Tray (3 dz cookies)

$48.95

Flavors

Mixed Variety

Nut Free

Custom Flavors -list special request

Xmas Buttercream Board

12 oz of our homemade buttercream frosting served with 16 shortbread "dippers".

$18.95

Christmas Shortbreads

Our classic shortbreads beautifully decorated for the holidays with delicious buttercream frosting! **We are not able to guarantee specific design requests the week of Christmas due to the large volume of orders**

Sprinkle Shortbreads

Our signature shortbread cookie topped with buttercream.

$2.50

Colors

Merry & Bright (pictured)

Traditional (red/green/white)

Hanukkah (blue/white)

Ginger Bread People

Enjoy our DELICIOUS & ADORABLE homemade Gingerbread Cookies! Decorated with buttercream accents

$4.50

Wreath Cookie Sandwich

Chocolate chip cookie (unless other flavor is requested) filled with buttercream and topped with a buttercream wreath!

Cookie Kits

Bring home the fun! Our cookie kits include 12 shortbread cookies, 3 colors of our famous buttercream icing and sprinkles. Share your creations; tag us @mrsgoodmans!

$29.95