OnlineOrdering | Mrs. Goodman's

ONLINE ORDERING: A minimum of 48 hours advanced notice is required to use the online ordering tool.

Please call the store (614)888-7437 for availability if you need items sooner.

If you do not receive an email confirmation & order number your order was NOT COMPLETED SUCCESSFULLY.

Pickup, ASAP (in 2 days)

FRUIT PIES
SEASONAL PIES
CREAM PIES
SPECIALTY "PIES"

Pies Cakes Cookies Cupcakes Scones Cinnamon Rolls Brownies Specialty Cakes Grab'n'Go Boxes Sweet Breads To-Go Wedding Tasting FRUIT PIES SEASONAL PIES CREAM PIES SPECIALTY "PIES"

Pies

Once upon a time, we were known as Mrs. Goodman's Pie Co. because our pies are so exceptional. Crusts are flaky, buttery and made from scratch, fillings are made with the finest ingredients. They say the world is divided into cake people and pie people, but here we believe you can be both.

FRUIT PIES

(call for daily offerings)

$29.9529.95 USD

$29.9529.95 USD

$29.9529.95 USD

SEASONAL PIES

$22.9522.95 USD

$35.9535.95 USD

Our delicious Pecan Pie topped with a chocolate drizzle

$35.9535.95 USD

Our delicious Pecan Pie topped with a white chocolate drizzle

$35.9535.95 USD

CREAM PIES

$25.9525.95 USD

$25.9525.95 USD

$25.9525.95 USD

$25.9525.95 USD

$25.9525.95 USD

$25.9525.95 USD

$25.9525.95 USD

$25.9525.95 USD

SPECIALTY "PIES"

A pie that is not a pie! Our delicious white cake filled with Bavarian cream filling and topped with chocolate ganache (and a cherry on top, of course!).

$28.9528.95 USD

Just like Boston Cream... a pie that's not really a pie! A perfect pairing of cranberries and walnuts adorn our famous vanilla cake creating a perfectly unique dessert experience!

$34.9534.95 USD

Cakes

Celebration Cakes

This order form is for STANDARD CAKE DESIGNS ONLY (balloons, dots, fireworks, etc...). Please see our "Custom Cakes" tab for custom requests!

Two layers of delicious cake with your choice of filling or buttercream in the center. 6" round cake serves 6-8 slices.

$34.9534.95 USD

Two layers of delicious cake with your choice of filling or buttercream in the center. 8" round cake serves 12-16 slices.

$48.9548.95 USD

Two layers of delicious cake with your choice of filling or buttercream in the center. 10" round cake serves 20-30 slices.

$64.9564.95 USD

9"x13" single layer cake with your choice of homemade icing. This cake cannot be made using 2 flavors. Quarter sheet cakes serve 16-24 slices.

$50.9550.95 USD

12"x18" single layer cake with your choice of homemade icing. Half sheet cakes serve 32-48.

$89.9589.95 USD

18"x 26" single layer cake with your choice of homemade icing. Full sheet cakes serve 64-96 slices.

$164.95164.95 USD

A single layer cake often used for 1st birthday photo shoots.

$24.9524.95 USD

Dessert Cakes

Enjoy these delectable flavor combinations!

REESE’S Perfect for the chocolate-peanut butter lover! Two layers of our signature chocolate cake filled with creamy peanut butter buttercream and iced with a combination of chocolate and peanut butter buttercream. Chocolate ganache and Reese's cups top this decadent creation. A customer favorite!

$39.9539.95 USD

COOKIES & CREAM Our signature chocolate cake with our original buttercream filling and smothered in our delicious cookies & cream buttercream. Topped with ganache and Oreo cookies. A classic combo!

$39.9539.95 USD

Your choice