top of page
ONLINE ORDERING: A minimum of 48 hours advanced notice is required to use the online ordering tool.
Please call the store (614)-888-7437 for availability if you need items sooner.
If you do not receive an email confirmation & order number your order was NOT COMPLETED SUCCESSFULLY.
Pickup, ASAP (in 2 days)
Cakes
Celebration Cakes
This order form is for STANDARD CAKE DESIGNS ONLY (balloons, dots, fireworks, etc...). Please click the "Custom Quotes" tab for custom design requests!
Two layers of delicious cake with your choice of filling or
buttercream in the center. 6" round cake serves 6-8 slices.34.95 USD
Two layers of delicious cake with your choice of filling or buttercream in the center. 8" round cake serves 12-16 slices.48.95 USD
Two layers of delicious cake with your choice of filling or buttercream in the center. 10" round cake serves 20-30 slices.64.95 USD
Please contact us at 614-888-7437 to inquire about our 12" (serves 30-40) and 14" (serves 45-60) large 2 layer cakes!0.00 USD
A single layer cake often used for 1st birthday photo shoots. 24.95 USD
9"x13" single layer cake with your choice of homemade icing. This cake cannot be made using 2 flavors. Quarter sheet cakes serve 16-24 slices.50.95 USD
12"x18" single layer cake with your choice of homemade icing. Half sheet cakes serve 32-48.89.95 USD
18"x 26" single layer cake with your choice of homemade icing. Full sheet cakes serve 64-96 slices.164.95 USD
Dessert Cakes
Enjoy these delectable flavor combinations!
REESE’S
Perfect for the chocolate-peanut butter lover! Two layers of our signature chocolate cake filled with creamy peanut butter buttercream and iced with a combination of chocolate and peanut butter buttercream. Chocolate ganache and Reese's cups top this decadent creation. A customer favorite! 39.95 USD
COOKIES & CREAM
Our signature chocolate cake with our original buttercream filling and smothered in our delicious cookies & cream buttercream. Topped with ganache and Oreo cookies. A classic combo!39.95 USD
Your choice of chocolate (recommended) or vanilla cake with our delicious chocolate buttercream, topped with brownie bites and cosmic candies.43.95 USD
Perfect for the coconut lover. Chocolate cake smothered in delicious almond buttercream, rolled in shaved coconut and topped with a chocolate ganache drizzle and chunks of Almond Joy candies. Just as good as the candy bar!39.95 USD
Feeling like you just need some MORE of our delicious buttercream? This cake has mounds of it! Your choice of our original chocolate or vanilla cake iced in our homemade buttercream and drizzled with ganache. We then top it with even MORE buttercream goodness! 39.95 USD
Our signature chocolate cake filled and covered in salted caramel buttercream and drizzled with chocolate and caramel. Heath Bar crumble around the base of the cake adds the perfect crunch.39.95 USD
Our signature vanilla cake iced in a combination of our original buttercream and strawberry buttercream. Topped with white chocolate ganache and mounds of more buttercream!39.95 USD
Your choice of vanilla (recommended) or chocolate cake and buttercream icing rolled in shaved coconut.39.95 USD
Available in one size - 8" (serves 12-16)54.95 USD
Enjoy our signature vanilla cake smothered in pumpkin buttercream icing and topped with a ribbon of our original buttercream. A perfect compliment to that PSL! 39.95 USD
A sprinkle lover's dream. Your choice of Funfetti (recommended), Vanilla, or Chocolate cake iced in sprinkle-infused buttercream. Topped with a ganache drip in your choice of color, and more of our delicious icing.39.95 USD
Vanilla cake filled with strawberries mixed with our homemade pastry cream and topped with whipped frosting and almond slivers. 43.95 USD
Chocolate cake filled with cherry filling and covered with whipped frosting and chocolate curls.43.95 USD
Cookie Cakes
Your dream cookie cake awaits! Select a cookie flavor, size and design to create the perfect sweet treat!16.95 USD
Holiday Menu 2024
Holiday Cakes
43.95 USD
43.95 USD
43.95 USD
43.95 USD
43.95 USD
43.95 USD
43.95 USD
73.95 USD
This 8" Yule Log is made using our delicious chocolate cake filled with original vanilla buttercream, coated in chocolate buttercream and adorned with beautiful poinsettias. Both a Christmas classic and beautiful table centerpiece. 49.95 USD
A smaller version of our full sphere ornament cake!
Serves 8-1044.95 USD
Almost too pretty to eat! Our full sphere ornament cake comes in chocolate or vanilla cake decorated to look like a beautiful Christmas ornament. Choose between Red, Green or Christmas Blue. Serves 20-2479.95 USD
43.95 USD
Our delicious chocolate cake filled with chocolate peppermint buttercream, covered in our original buttercream and topped with chocolate ganache and candy canes. 43.95 USD
Just like Boston Cream... a pie that's not really a pie! A perfect pairing of cranberries and walnuts adorn our famous vanilla cake creating a perfectly unique dessert experience!42.95 USD
Cookies!
Our classic shortbreads beautifully decorated for the holidays with delicious buttercream frosting! **We are not able to guarantee specific design requests the week of Christmas due to the large volume of orders**4.00 USD
Our signature shortbread cookie topped with buttercream. 2.25 USD
They're back for a second year! Enjoy our homemade Gingerbread Cookies! Decorated with buttercream accents4.00 USD
Chocolate chip cookie (unless other flavor is requested) filled with buttercream and topped with a buttercream wreath!6.00 USD
Bring home the fun! Our cookie kits include 12 shortbread cookies, 3 colors of our famous buttercream icing and sprinkles. Share your creations; tag us @mrsgoodmans!29.95 USD
They're back! Must order multiples of 6. 10.50 USD
Cupcakes & Brownies
Our delicious brownie with a festive buttercream twist! 6.00 USD
Our delicious brownie topped with chocolate peppermint buttercream. Mouth. Watering. 6.00 USD
Chocolate chip cookie (unless other flavor is requested) filled with buttercream and topped with a buttercream wreath!6.00 USD
3.50 USD
4.25 USD
3.50 USD
2.95 USD
Cookies & Bars
Homemade Cookies
A delightful blend of warm spices and rich molasses! Topped with a dollop of buttercream and a sliver of candied ginger. NOT included in baker's dozen special.2.25 USD
NOT included in baker's dozen special.
*SEASONAL* Available in the fall/winter months only.3.50 USD
13 of our delicious homemade cookies (buy 12 get 1 FREE)! Include quantities of flavors under Special Requests. Pumpkin Spice cookies not included in the Baker's Dz. 27.00 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
2.25 USD
Your choice of cookie with vanilla buttercream sandwiched between.6.00 USD
Shortbread Cookies with Famous Buttercream
Choose between decorated or a scarlet & gray sprinkle mix (or both!). 2.25 USD
Shortbread cookies topped with our famous buttercream and your choice of sprinkles!2.25 USD
Leave your request for sprinkle colors under "Special Requests". 3.25 USD
Bring home the fun! Our cookie kits include 12 shortbread cookies, 3 colors of our famous buttercream icing and sprinkles. NOTE THE 3 COLORS YOU'D LIKE UNDER SPECIAL REQUESTS. Share your creations; tag us @mrsgoodmans!29.95 USD
Bars
Chewy, delicious pecan filling topped over a buttery shortbread crust. A must for your holiday table!4.00 USD
3.50 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
Cupcakes
Cupcakes
Add a birthday message to your cupcakes!
If ordering multiple cupcakes and only one plaque let us know which cupcake to add it to under "Special Requests".0.55 USD
Our vanilla cupcake filled with our delicious homemade pastry cream and topped with chocolate buttercream and whipped cream. Finished with a cherry on top, of course!3.50 USD
A caramel lovers dream! Our vanilla cupcake filled with the best homemade caramel you've ever tasted! Topped with caramel buttercream with little extra drizzle. 3.50 USD
2.95 USD
2.95 USD
Topped with our homemade Cream Cheese Frosting
(nut-free; made with carrots and pineapple)2.95 USD
2.95 USD
2.95 USD
Chocolate cupcake topped with a decadent combination of our rich chocolate buttercream and our German chocolate filling. 2.95 USD
Topped with our homemade Cream Cheese Frosting2.95 USD
2.95 USD
A Funfetti cupcake paired with buttercream icing & rainbow sprinkles2.95 USD
While this is a gluten free recipe, gluten is used throughout our kitchen. We are careful not to cross-contaminate, however, those with severe allergies should exercise extreme caution and use your own discretion.3.50 USD
While this is a gluten free recipe, gluten is used throughout our kitchen. We are careful not to cross-contaminate, however, those with severe allergies should exercise extreme caution and use your own discretion.3.50 USD
A Gluten Friendly funfetti cupcake with rainbow sprinkles3.50 USD
Scones
Scones
4.25 USD
4.25 USD
4.25 USD
4.25 USD
4.25 USD
4.25 USD
4.25 USD
4.25 USD
3.50 USD
Frozen Scones
Bring home our famous scones and bake when you're ready! Bake at 350 degrees for 25-35 minutes (depending on your oven) until the edges are golden!
Bring home our famous scones and bake when you're ready!
Bake at 350 degrees for 30-35 minutes (depending on your oven) or until the edges are golden!4.25 USD
Cinnamon Rolls
Cinnamon Rolls
Baked fresh every morning.4.00 USD
Baked fresh every morning, then topped with delicious homemade buttercream. 4.00 USD
Baked fresh every morning, then topped with pecans. 4.50 USD
Brownies
Brownies
Welcome to Chocolate Lovers' Paradise
5.50 USD
We've added chocolate chip cookies to our already delicious brownies- how can you resist this combo?5.00 USD
5.50 USD
5.50 USD
5.50 USD
4.50 USD
Cream Pies & Fruit Crumbles
Cream Pies
Banana Cream Pie served in a graham cracker crust25.95 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
Chocolate Cream Pie served in a graham cracker crust25.95 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie served in a graham cracker crust25.95 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
Coconut Cream Pie served in a graham cracker crust25.95 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
A Mrs. Goodman's take on a Pumpkin Cream Pie served in a 10" graham cracker crust. Serves 8-1025.95 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
Peanut Butter Cream Pie served in a graham cracker crust25.95 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
25.95 USD
Silky smooth chocolate pie serves in a chocolate crust25.95 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
Crumbles
Our homemade apple pie filling topped with our signature crumb topping. Pro tip: serve with a scoop of vanilla ice cream!25.95 USD
Our delicious cherry pie filling topped with our signature crumb topping. Pro tip: serve with a scoop of vanilla ice cream!25.95 USD
Our delicious peach pie filling topped with our signature crumb topping. Pro tip: serve with a scoop of vanilla ice cream!25.95 USD
Cheesecakes
Cheesecakes
Special
Our homemade cheesecake with Oreo bits throughout, topped with cookies & cream buttercream! (Oreo crust) *Requires 3 day lead time!64.95 USD
Specialty Cakes
Specialty Cakes
Available in one size - 8" (serves 12-16)54.95 USD
A pie that is not a pie! Our delicious white cake filled with pastry cream filling and topped with chocolate ganache (and a cherry on top, of course!). 32.95 USD
Special
22.95 USD
An elegant angel food cake with orange buttercream icing. (Best served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream or whipped cream!) Serves 12+.34.95 USD
16.95 USD
Just like Boston Cream... a pie that's not really a pie! A perfect pairing of cranberries and walnuts adorn our famous vanilla cake creating a perfectly unique dessert experience!42.95 USD
Grab'n'Go Boxes
Grab'n'Go Boxes
9.95 USD