For over 30 years Mrs. Goodman's has specialized in custom (and delicious) cakes to make every occasion a little SWEETER.  

Our family's primary mission is to create an extraordinary wedding cake to match your unique taste, style and budget. In addition to our memorable wedding cakes, we are known for our superior service, attention to every detail, and of course, a host of delectable treats for your dessert table or wedding favors.

Consultations look a little different these days!  We now offer "to-go tastings" in lieu of an onsite consultation. For $10 you will receive:

-four cake samples: white, chocolate, red velvet and almond cake (unless otherwise requested) 

-five filling samples: raspberry (fruit), strawberry (fruit), lemon (fruit), cream cheese (icing) and chocolate buttercream (icing)

-our famous buttercream (used on the exterior of all tiered cakes)

Once a flavor selection has been made you will work with one of our cake decorators to discuss your wedding cake vision. 


901 High Street

Worthington, OH 43085



Tue - Sat: 9am - 2pm

Sun - Mon: Closed


© 2018 by Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.